A Woman is a Woman
1961 ‘Une femme est une femme’ Directed by Jean-Luc Godard
Synopsis
Exotic dancer Angéla attempts to have a child with her unwilling lover Émile. In the process, she finds herself torn between him and his best friend Alfred.
Popular reviews
More-
Part of **No Re-Watch November 2012**.
"Je pense que J'existe."**
I wonder how many times Zooey Deschanel has seen this picture? Anna Karina's Angela has got to be the model for her entire persona. Zooey has carved away the undercurrent of sadness, though. That undercurrent makes for extra depth of character that Zooey never has -- and also adds about twenty levels of crazy. Here, she's a stripper obsessed with having a baby. Her boyfriend won't do it, but his best friend Alfred would willingly take one for the team. (It's funny seeing Jean-Paul Belmondo play the sweet, slightly dorky Alfred after his turn as the dangerous charmer in Breathless.) Speaking of Zooey: Angela and her boyfriend have an amusing…
-
And so continues my love-hate tug-of-war towards Jean-Luc Godard. It's pretty funny, his shtick is to infuse his characters and story with self-awareness and obnoxious design elements like attention-grabbing sound effects or on-screen titles. By today's standards, these pieces of flair, if you will, would be considered decent for a student thesis film, or "hipster" for those who don't know what existed in this world before 1980. I find that whenever I watch Godard I have to force myself into the mindset where I recognize that before this, there was pretty much just stuffy over-produced Hollywood musicals, romances, and hardly-historical epics and that Godard was scaring the monocles off of Hollywood faces with his loose structures and cocky style. Still,…
-
Jean-Luc Godard uses a wonderfully playful style to explore the complexities of love and gender. One of the lesser known delights of the French New Wave movement, rich in visual pleasures. From the magnificent beauty of It star, Anna Karina, to the suave culture of its setting. 40 years later and its lasting appeal is confirmed. Watching this feels like going on a vacation back in time, Godard captures the heart of early 60s French society.
Starting off shaky, with messy editing and awkward on-and-off music, but once Anna Karina warms up the the screen all begins to fall in place. Playing Angela Recamier, a strip artist who desperately wants a baby, but is unable to convince her boyfriend, Emile…
-
Jean-Luc Godard's second feature film is a wonderfully refreshing romantic comedy. It is supposed to be a musical, but it isn't a musical in the traditional sense of the word. Music comes in brief, loud bursts, or is silenced so that the viewer pays more attention to the lyrics being sung.
As Godard's first colour film, he didn't waste the opportunity to experiment with colour, and used his colour schemes to their fullest potential. The costumes, lighting, and sets all explode from the screen in bright oranges, reds, purples, and blues; making for a very "kaleidoscopic" experience.
The best way to view A Woman is a Woman is to surrender yourself to the film and the quirkiness of the characters.
-
Continuing Godard's fascination with shitting on the fourth wall, this time in musical comedy form, comes his first cinemascope colour film. A unique and idiosyncratic work, as to be expected.
A Woman is a Woman features far less forced philosophy with much more delightful smug charm than his other films that i have seen, there are no intruding titlecards for the most part and speaking into the camera in poetic ramblings is reduced to few and far. Anna Karina is adorable, though i made the mistake of googling her and realizing women get old. Another ''anti-movie'' from Godard, but much more playful in its defiance. Which i ended up liking quite a bit. -
A hugely interesting film, fascinating in its remarkable ability to tear a familiar genre down to its bare elements, inspect them thoroughly, and then cobble them back together to form an enjoyable film. A Woman is a Woman toys with the conventions of romantic films in an extremely playful manner, deconstructing the well-trodden formula to expose the deceit that lies behind these stories. Intriguing as it is though, Godard's film is too structurally loose, too theoretical, and—most importantly of all—too dramatically unengaging to be anything more than a curious exercise. It's well and good to take these characters as ciphers through whom to examine familiar plots and their construction, but I also need to be caught up in their actual relationship, something I never was. The ideas behind A Woman is a Woman engage my mind; without engaging my heart too, the impact is a little wasted.
Recent reviews
More-
Godard in the '60s is pretty much untouchable.
-
As always, Godard create an interesting and unique film - however, excess melodrama diminishes it.
-
A success of stylistic experimentation that is at once both odd & beautiful. Karina is charming. #see
-
This is how you do the romantic comedy at its most musical and exuberant. Quirky, but emotionally resonant, it doesn't get much better than A Woman is a Woman, where Jean-Luc Godard and Anna Karina create a world you want to live in.
-
Wow. This was really good. I would put it at number 8 of my all time favorites.
Let me just point out the fact that I shouldn't like this movie so much, especially in the mood I've been in. I'm feeling heartbroken and slightly depressed. And I don't know why. Actually, no. Maybe that is why I liked this movie so much.
A woman (a stripper. Yes. A stripper. But a damn classy one at that.) wants a baby really badly and her boyfriend Emile won't agree. They quarrel about it for a bit and she she starts to consider random people to impregnate her. Then she thinks her friend would fit the bill nicely. Then her boyfriend gets upset…
-
Utterly unbearable; a mannered collection of scenes that, like most of the Godard I've seen, felt more like a lecture on ideas of cinema than a film in its own right.
-
Jean-Luc Godard's second feature film is a wonderfully refreshing romantic comedy. It is supposed to be a musical, but it isn't a musical in the traditional sense of the word. Music comes in brief, loud bursts, or is silenced so that the viewer pays more attention to the lyrics being sung.
As Godard's first colour film, he didn't waste the opportunity to experiment with colour, and used his colour schemes to their fullest potential. The costumes, lighting, and sets all explode from the screen in bright oranges, reds, purples, and blues; making for a very "kaleidoscopic" experience.
The best way to view A Woman is a Woman is to surrender yourself to the film and the quirkiness of the characters.
-
Now this is the Godard that I like! Playful, winking, funny, rule-breaking. While it may not be as great as the similarly-styled Pierrot le fou (few films are), this film was very enjoyable. Anna Karina plays Angela, a beautiful striptease artist who wants to have a child. Unfortunately, her boyfriend, Émile, isn't quite convinced. Upset, Angela tells Émile she'll ask the next man she sees if he'll have a baby with her, at which point Émile invites his friend Alfred, who happens to be in love with Angela, to their home. Will Angela take the opportunity to have a child with Alfred, or will she remain faithful to Émile? The film explicitly ponders to itself if it is a comedy…
-
Right at the beginning, when Anna Karina breaks the fourth wall at the coffee shop and blinks to the camera, that's when my heart goes ownnn :3.