Groaning audibly, electronically, together, since September 2011. forums.hipinion.com/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=50619
Atlas Shrugged Part I
Who is John Galt?
A powerful railroad executive, Dagny Taggart, struggles to keep her business alive while society is crumbling around her. Based on the 1957 novel by Ayn Rand.
The book Atlas Shrugged is a vile thing partially redeemed by the rubberneck value of seeing an author’s scarred psyche and bigotry transformed into a meticulously thought-out yet repellent philosophy that denies the existence of abstract beauty or humanity. Reading it is an alternately hilarious and disturbing experience, but it helps you understand the workings of the moneymen who arrogantly and incorrectly assume that their blind luck and ruthlessness in gaming the system is evidence of their Übermenschian superiority over the riff-raff.
Atlas Shrugged: Part I can’t even get that right. It’s incoherent and tedious, as soulless as the people who find value in it, and yet mundanely evil. It advocates the worst behaviour, it celebrates the worst of our…
To be clear, I'd give the movie 0 stars but I don't want you to think I didn't give it a rating at all.
A lot of people who have given this movie a bad review (and there were a LOT of people who have done so) have been accused of simply disagreeing with the film's political stance, and to be fair the film makes its socio-political views very clear. That's not why this is a bad movie, though. This is a bad movie because it's a dull, overwrought, poorly-written and poorly-acted affair. I may not be the biggest Ayn Rand fan in existence, but the woman was a good writer and Atlas Shrugged is a well-written story. John Aglialoro and Brian Patrick O'Toole, the writers behind this film, are clearly not anywhere near her or your average screenwriter's league. To be fair, they…
It's technically serviceable but that can only get you so far when your production is plagued by wooden acting and TV-movie mise en scene. Unlike The Fountainhead, which I admit I enjoyed (both the film and the book), and regardless of your personal views on Rand's literature or philosophy, the material here just doesn't translate well into film, and especially not as a vehicle for Rand's political ideology. No amount of screen magic can make a film about a fucking railroad exciting (or at least it would take a team of talent many orders of magnitude more skilled than the one on display here), and when you pair it up with Rand's two-dimensional mouthpieces engaging in dry monologues about the…
I have not seen this movie, but I have to share a story a friend just shared with me about seeing this movie in the theater.
My friend went to see this movie when it opened in San Diego. The theater was packed. He was sitting three rows behind an older man sitting by himself. A group of five college students entered the theater and looked for five seats together where they could sit. Seeing a number of seats open around the older man, they politely asked him if he wouldn't mind moving towards the middle so they could sit together. He looked at them and said passionately, "No. This is my seat." Shocked, the college students separated and sat in two different groups. Here's to you, Ayn Rand.
Not even redeemable from a filmic point of view, let alone the whole objectivisim thing, which is also stupid.
Atlas Shrugged: Part 1 - This adaption of Ayn Rand's seminal book is a total train wreck; I can't fathom how this was ever released! (C-)
The only one of the group I'd seen before today, it's just as miserable as it was the first time I saw it. You just want to shake every character and ask what on earth they're thinking. Ayn Rand was a piece of shit with a garbage philosophy, but at least she bothered to explain herself; these movies assume you're already on board and they sprint out of the gate with that assumption. Still, it actually looks like a real movie, and there's real actors in it, which is more than can be said for the others. By comparison it's not bad, even though by itself it's truly wretched.
I liked the adaptation thus far... (own on DVD)
If I was forced to make a choice between watching this again or shooting my own dick off, I'd already be loading the gun.
"Not a great film. Not a bad film. Certainly unfairly savaged by a large number of critics. I haven't read the book but didn't have any trouble following the fairly simple plot. The complaints of wooden dialog might fairly apply to the occasional line delivery but overall the performances were more nuanced that I had been led to expect. It gave me a bit of the sense of a ""Heaven's Gate"" with epic aspirations falling short but not nearly as far short as ""Heaven's Gate"" fell.
I'm sufficiently interested that I'll be there for Part II if it makes it to the screen - and even be a bit disappointed if it doesn't."
The silliness of the last sequence will go down as one of the worst but funniest events in flop history.
Too bad the shrug turned out to be contagious...
Knowing nothing of the title or anything associated with this film, at first I was excited, thinking that this was an ambitious, original, dystopian screenplay of the near future. Its not; its a novel adaptation, which basically makes this a politically charged soap opera. Since so many reviewers want to curse this for its complete lack of humanity, I will cite the protagonist's determination in spite of adversity, maybe thats worth something. Any serious debate of the story falls under the jurisdiction of economic theorists and literary critics, not film critics.
Only a movie this shitty could make looking at Taylor Schilling for 90 minutes a chore.
Awful source material, nonsensical acting, and worse direction/editing than the greenest film student. Anyone who thinks this film is any good a) doesn't know film, or b) is grinding a pro-Ayn Rand axe.
- Weekend at Bernie's
- Weekend at Bernie's II
- Battlefield Earth
- Pirates of Silicon Valley
- Ernest Scared Stupid
- Blade Runner
- The Matrix
- Natural City
For all your dystopian cyberpunk fixes.
- Rock of Ages
- That's My Boy
- Dark Shadows
- American Reunion
I've decided to start a list of new(wide) releases that I am confident I'll never see. EVER! I'll be happy…