Leaves Out of the Book of Satan
1921 ‘Blade af Satans Bog’ Directed by Carl Theodor Dreyer
Synopsis
Dreyer's classic silent film tells the tale of Satan's (Helge Nissen) banishment from heaven.
Popular reviews
More-
Carl Theodor Dreyer - Leaves Out of the Book of Satan (1920)
This film is in many ways quite similar to Griffith’s Intolerance (1916). The script to Leaves Out of the Book of Satan is however from 1913 so it can't have been influenced by Intolerance. Most likely, both films were inspired by Satanas (dir. Luigi Maggi), an Italian film from 1912. Still, Dreyer did probably know about and see Griffith's film so it must have been there somewhere in his head when he was making this.
The film is in four chapters, four stories about how Satan temps people, the first in the last days of Jesus, the 2nd in the Spanish inquisition, the 3rd in the French Revolution…
-
Leaves From Satan's Book is a minor work from the Danish masterclass director Carl Theodor Dreyer. While knowing that in advance and not having large expectations, I still wanted to see this film for the interesting concept and story. It is a four part segmented story each taking place in a different major event in history all with Satan embodying a certain figure of that era and is from his perspective.
But the result I got even with lowered expectations was pretty much what many of the reviews I had read warned about. Overall I would say the major issue with this film is it is a non-visual silent film which is doomed to fail. Silent cinema relies on visual…
Recent reviews
More-
Carl Theodor Dreyer - Leaves Out of the Book of Satan (1920)
This film is in many ways quite similar to Griffith’s Intolerance (1916). The script to Leaves Out of the Book of Satan is however from 1913 so it can't have been influenced by Intolerance. Most likely, both films were inspired by Satanas (dir. Luigi Maggi), an Italian film from 1912. Still, Dreyer did probably know about and see Griffith's film so it must have been there somewhere in his head when he was making this.
The film is in four chapters, four stories about how Satan temps people, the first in the last days of Jesus, the 2nd in the Spanish inquisition, the 3rd in the French Revolution…
-
Leaves From Satan's Book is a minor work from the Danish masterclass director Carl Theodor Dreyer. While knowing that in advance and not having large expectations, I still wanted to see this film for the interesting concept and story. It is a four part segmented story each taking place in a different major event in history all with Satan embodying a certain figure of that era and is from his perspective.
But the result I got even with lowered expectations was pretty much what many of the reviews I had read warned about. Overall I would say the major issue with this film is it is a non-visual silent film which is doomed to fail. Silent cinema relies on visual…
-
4 Pages of the Book. (1-2-3)-4
Temptations, not assaults from the Satan; the Evil is just there, doing its duty as it is supposed to do, the conscience lies on the individuals, on whether they are going to make a certain decision or the other. We, as selves, are emotional, thinking that external events (politics, religion, wars) are emotional as well. Satan is emotionless, only hinting at regret when he succeeds in his temptations. Until the final decision is made, he is going to push the envelope until the end.
As the saying "Do the right thing" is simple and hypocritical, Dreyer's Leaves, a collection of allegories across history, the everlasting cycle, is perfectly lucid, yet painful in drawing out… -
Dreyer's stab at the conceit of D.W. Griffith's Intolerance works primarily for its intentions, as the four connected storylines are all markedly mundane in their orchestration. The first one - which posits the tale of Judas working under the hand of Satan - is actually a whole lot more interesting for its classically Danish Jesus (complete with the strict, dark beard) who is, above all things, pretty snide. Moving into the Spanish Inquisition (where a love triangle just gets sillier and sillier as it fumbles along), on to the French Revolution and modern times (both stories are shamelessly similar to the Spanish Inquisition bit), Dreyer is still nearly a decade from his masterpiece (The Passion of Joan of Arc) - and it shows. He does - in three don't-blink moments - move the camera.
-
An engaging yet captivating story about temptation as Satan is banished from Heaven to Earth as he lives in four different periods to test people to see if he can reduce his sentence of eternal damnation.
-
Sad face Satan. Marie’s march has a hint of of late Dreyer. Ivan’s crowd a touch of Joan. Hide yo kids, hide yo wives. Satan in a position of power rather than simply a position of influence; without the power would anyone listen? Cutting to a random close-up a technique to remember.
-
Feels very dated and not a patch on Joan of Arc, but a decent watch anyway.