Sarah's Key
2011 ‘Elle s'appelait Sarah’ Directed by Gilles Paquet-Brenner
Synopsis
On the night of 16 July 1942, ten year old Sarah and her parents are being arrested and transported to the Velodrome d'Hiver in Paris where thousands of other jews are being send to get deported. Sarah however managed to lock her little brother in a closed just before the police entered their appartment.Sixty years later, Julia Jarmond, an American journalist in Paris, gets the assignment to write an article about this raid, a black page in the history of France. She starts digging archives and through Sarah's file discovers a well kept secret about her own in-laws.
Cast
Studio
Popular reviews
More-
Sarah's Key is a fragmented tale telling two stories simultaneously from 1942 France and present day Paris. Normally with films structured in a past and present setting, one story tends to overshadow the other instead of complimenting each other like intended. This was also the case with Sarah's Key and not to be too harsh, it is a tough scripting structure to get right.
The film is based on a novel of the same title written by Tatiana De Rosnay. The book was a critical success and the film spawned shortly after its publication. It delves into the lives of a Jewish family in 1942 Paris being deported to concentration camps in Germany at the hands of their own countrymen.…
-
A moving story that takes place in 1940's France as well as present day France and America. There's a ton of movies having to do with WWII so I was afraid it would just be another mediocre film on the subject, but I quite enjoyed this film and would recommend it to anyone.
-
Elle s'appelait Sarah
"Not for the fainthearted, (although most of the bits that might make a faint heart quail aren't shown), but I found this a well-acted film with an interesting story." -
Sarah's Key is an interesting story that, whilst it isn't always emotionally captivating, has a small number of powerful scenes that will tear you up. Kristen Scott Thomas suits the lead role incredibly well and there are many other decent performances, too, especially from the younger actors who are the ones that make the story so compelling. It doesn't always hold your attention, but it open and ends beautifully.
-
Having read nothing about this film, I watched it on a whim last night and was pleasantly surprised. Not only was it a lesson in History that I wasn't fully aware of in the French deportation of Jews to Nazi concentration camps but it was a very well made film, albeit a sad one. If you like Boy in the Striped Pajamas then I recommend this.
-
Sometimes, you just feel like watching something gut-wrenchingly depressing that also happens to have your name in the title. I was, strangely, in the mood for a SUPER sad movie, which is why I decided to stream this on Netflix on Friday night. This fit the bill, and was actually a really well done film. I loved the jumping back and forth in time (which added a bit of mystery and connection to the present in a story that could have been fairly straight-forward), and it was incredibly well-acted. This has been on my list for awhile now, and I'm glad I finally took the depressing plunge.
Recent reviews
More-
Sometimes, you just feel like watching something gut-wrenchingly depressing that also happens to have your name in the title. I was, strangely, in the mood for a SUPER sad movie, which is why I decided to stream this on Netflix on Friday night. This fit the bill, and was actually a really well done film. I loved the jumping back and forth in time (which added a bit of mystery and connection to the present in a story that could have been fairly straight-forward), and it was incredibly well-acted. This has been on my list for awhile now, and I'm glad I finally took the depressing plunge.
-
A basically good movie that makes a few serious mistakes. Kristin Scott Thomas plays a newspaper reporter in Paris who discovers her husband's family's apartment was confiscated from a Jewish family during WWII. The intercutting between a young girl's attempt to save her life during the Holocaust and Kristin Scott Thomas's marriage problems create the impression that the film thinks they are somehow comparable, which they are surely not. Also, there's a tendency to use Thomas's newspaper colleagues to simply state the film's rhetorical points, which makes for dull pedantic scenes that bring the film to a crashing halt. The second half of the film is markedly less interesting. After having watched the girl's WWII ordeal, watching Thomas try to sort out her own feelings about it can't help but be less interesting.
-
Sarah's Key is a fragmented tale telling two stories simultaneously from 1942 France and present day Paris. Normally with films structured in a past and present setting, one story tends to overshadow the other instead of complimenting each other like intended. This was also the case with Sarah's Key and not to be too harsh, it is a tough scripting structure to get right.
The film is based on a novel of the same title written by Tatiana De Rosnay. The book was a critical success and the film spawned shortly after its publication. It delves into the lives of a Jewish family in 1942 Paris being deported to concentration camps in Germany at the hands of their own countrymen.…
-
Sarah's Key is an interesting story that, whilst it isn't always emotionally captivating, has a small number of powerful scenes that will tear you up. Kristen Scott Thomas suits the lead role incredibly well and there are many other decent performances, too, especially from the younger actors who are the ones that make the story so compelling. It doesn't always hold your attention, but it open and ends beautifully.
-
I generally have a quite big interest for World War 2, and I have seen a lot of WW2 movies, but Sarah's Key was a lot different from those I've watched before. The cinematography in this movie is great, with the switching between Sarah'a life during WW2, and the journalist digging up her life story in 2009. During this intricate story, she learns that she and Sarah are deeply connected, and that's where things start to become interesting... Really well-made!
-
Having read nothing about this film, I watched it on a whim last night and was pleasantly surprised. Not only was it a lesson in History that I wasn't fully aware of in the French deportation of Jews to Nazi concentration camps but it was a very well made film, albeit a sad one. If you like Boy in the Striped Pajamas then I recommend this.
-
Originally published on July 30, 2011.
Those who found 2008’s The Boy with the Striped Pajamas offensive in the way that it made a melodrama out of child deaths in the Holocaust need not consider seeing Sarah’s Key, for it plays much the same manipulative tune. While Sarah’s historically liberal depiction of Nazi-inflicted brutality may not anger certain viewers in the way that Pajamas’ did because it was at least inspired by a true story, the film once again raises the question: Can we reduce the Holocaust to a Lifetime drama? Granted, the performances of Sarah’s Key are far better than those that would grace the weepy women’s network -- Mélusine Mayance is gut-wrenching as the eponymous young girl, delivering…
-
Kristen Scott Thomas continues to prove that she can play anyone, in any time, and anywhere. Here, she plays an American journalist living in France who is writing an extended magazine piece about the French government/police's active persecution of Jews during World War II. The film is told in both the present and the past, as Thomas' character is linked, in a wonderful and poignant way, with a little Jewish girl (Sarah) and her story. It's a terrific film and quite moving in both temporal incarnations. I recommend it to anyone who enjoys contemporary French cinema.
-
One of those rare situations where the movie is better (in this case not only better, but far better) than the book. Thank the film gods they diminished or eliminated nearly everything about the novel that sucked.