Didn't expect to like this so much. Great story and some stellar performances. Most notably Jackman and Hathaway.

Visually stunning. Joaquin Phoenix is un-frickin-believable. I was just slightly bored by the story.

This is a special film. probably one of the darkest and depressing I've ever seen too. Truely heartbreaking and totally absorbing. I was on the verge of tears throughout most of the final third.

I've not seen a film being so elequent about human hardship since 'The Squid and the Whale'.

Good wee movie. It's a weird one though. I had no interest in this until everyone started going mad. It's hard to have an objective opinion on it without having the hype influence your thoughts in some way.

All I can say is that I enjoyed it and was entertained. I liked the novelty of a soundless story and the alternative focus this brings to the movie experience.