One Room With A View’s review published on Letterboxd:
Portraying someone in a work of art inevitably means gathering intimate details about their life. The way they blush when they’re angry, the way they bite their lip when they’re embarrassed, and the way they truly feel deep in their heart. Céline Sciamma’s masterful Portrait of a Lady on Fire offers a female gaze which suggests these aesthetic details are enough to reveal the deepest secrets of someone’s life.
Sciamma’s gendered gaze feels like an honest solution to the way women once had to (and often still do) live their lives. Opportunities to openly discuss their true feelings were rare in the face of forced marriages or unwanted pregnancies so communication came through looks and silences.
This is even more true for queer women, as an inevitable consequence of taboo feelings. Sciamma uses this silence to brilliant effect, emphasising the secrecy of the relationship between Marianne (Noémie Merlant) and Héloïse (Adèle Haenel), heightening its eroticism with intimate whispers. Sciamma only uses a musical score at two moments and they’re lethal enough to remind you of the power of sound and images combined. It feels like nothing other than witchcraft when the needles drop and drive home emotions that were previously restrained.
Little backstory is given for any of the leads, which weakens the characterisation at times, but ultimately Sciamma’s ability to reveal telling details with her camera is enough.
Claire Mathon’s ravishing photography makes this one of the most beautiful films of the year, and Haenel and Merlant are astonishing in the lead roles, fencing with their feelings and revealing as little and as much as they dare.
Reminiscent of both Call Me by Your Name and Phantom Thread, Sciamma’s love story deserves to be recognised as its own incredible take on queerness, love, and the power of art to communicate both.