CinemaClown’s review published on Letterboxd :
Whenever an acclaimed novel is chosen for a film adaptation, the biggest concern its fans generally have is whether or not the film will capture the essence of the story in the same manner as the author did. So when it was decided to bring J.R.R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings on silver screen, the expectation was so monumental that the trilogy was almost doomed to fail, for this legendary Middle-Earth saga was no mere literary work but over the years had garnered such an unprecedented following that it was deemed 'unfilmable' by many, including Tolkien himself.
Nevertheless, the first trailers were enthusiastically received & the anticipation kept building until in December 2001, everyone from Tolkien fans to critics & cinephiles lined up just to see if the first chapter of the most ambitious project ever undertaken in cinema history will live up to its surmounting hype or not. And not only did The Fellowship of the Ring succeed in surpassing all the sky-high expectations with effortless ease but brought alive Middle-Earth in such breathtaking detail that it set a whole new standard for epic filmmaking, which remains unsurpassed as of today.
The Lord of the Rings was meant to be seen as a single work divided into three volumes and so is the case with its film adaptation. Opening with a brilliantly narrated prologue that welcomes even the newcomers into its world with smooth comfort while setting the tone for the upcoming events, The Fellowship of the Ring tells the story of a hobbit named Frodo Baggins who inadvertently possesses the One Ring that once belonged to the Dark Lord Sauron, and is ultimately tasked with the mission to destroy it before it falls into the hands of the evil. The subtitle refers to the fellowship of companions who join Frodo in his quest.
Director Peter Jackson was a relatively unknown filmmaker until he helmed this project and what really helped the cause is that he really understands the Tolkien's world, being a Middle-Earth fan himself. The screenplay he co-wrote with Fran Walsh & Philippa Boyens is structured to have a universal appeal so that it could please both fans of the book as well as first-time viewers. Jackson's direction is even more impressive as every single aspect achieves perfection under his distinct cinematic vision and the emphasis given to the smallest of details is highly admirable as well.
Coming to the technical aspects, production design is a masterwork of stunning craftsmanship, for the set pieces are absolutely gorgeous to look at. The beautiful landscapes of New Zealand stand in for Middle-Earth and all of it is splendidly photographed, plus the camera also makes terrific use of lighting, composition, inventive angles & surroundings to provide a timeless sense of being in a completely different but endlessly fascinating world. Make-up & costume design are also meticulously carried out while Sound breaks new ground and captures each moment with stunning clarity.
The one restriction a film faces but a book doesn't is its length. Even 3 hours of runtime fell short in capturing the first volume of Tolkien's epic saga but whatever Jackson & his crew managed to fit in those 178 minutes still makes up for an epic ride. The extended edition adds 30 minutes of additional footage which further develops its characters, adds greater depth & enhances the overall experience drastically. Yet the most groundbreaking aspect remains its visual effects which elevates this film to an undisputed level of grandeur beauty while Howard Shore's spellbinding score further enhances the experience with majestic & mesmerising tracks.
Almost every film requires at least three ingredients to come out as a great product; A smartly-written script, a talented director who understands the script & has the vision to realise it on the screen, and a skilled cast that can infuse new life into these scripted characters. The Lord of the Rings gets the first two ingredients right and a mistake in the third could've been catastrophic to its fortunes, only that it wasn't because the assembled cast is simply pitch-perfect, for they seamlessly fit their fictional characters & are extremely convincing in their given roles.
On an overall scale, the on-screen adaptation of The Lord of the Rings commences on a perfect note without discarding any of the elements that made Tolkien's works immortal. It begins the journey with its cleverly written prologue, immerses viewers into its world with its intriguing plot, dazzles them with its beautiful photography & visuals, connects them with its wonderfully fleshed-out characters who further benefit from sincere performances, amazes them with thrilling action sequences, and provides a heightened sense of emotions at all times with its heartwarming score.
A film that is able to achieve even a few of what's stated above is pretty much destined to succeed but when it accomplishes every single one of these aspects, then it becomes something else entirely, and that's what The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring is: A magical blend of art & entertainment, a landmark moment in cinema history, a genre-defining masterpiece, a timeless classic & a jaw-dropping cinematic experience that's epic in every sense of the word. Undoubtedly one of the greatest films ever made, The Fellowship of the Ring is cinema at its most breathtaking.
Full review at: wp.me/p3KleJ-gs