Every now and again I wrestle with Howard Ashman's assessment of whether the musical can work in live action films. Though Ashman was firmly against it, there seem to be a solid amount of exceptions to his statements: Singing in the Rain, Moulin Rouge, Once, Meet Me in St. Louis, the Muppet Movie (only slightly kidding about that one).
Into the Woods reminds me that Ashman was mostly correct.
Completely atonal and with a screenplay that lacks any of the…