Matt DeTurck’s review published on Letterboxd :
Disappointing and disjointed. Nothing amounts to much, the cast is wasted, and the B-plot is virtually pointless.
PROS: A great cast (even though they're wasted), a good Bear McCreary score, and some bright-and-colorful lighting design.
Otherwise, it's definitely a huge waste of the Cloverfield name and the possibilities it sets up.