Chuck’s review published on Letterboxd :
Has it really been 10 years since this movie was in theaters? I guess it has! At the time, it had been seven years since Nemesis was released, and four years since Enterprise was on television. The Star Trek franchise was tanned, rested, and ready.
They set out to do something different, and they certainly did, by employing the "alternate timeline" MacGuffin. Leonard Nimoy's appearance is what really made me want to see the movie back then (minor spoiler: there are two Spocks in this movie). Earth is in danger, and only the crew of the Enterprise can save it. It's a good start to a "revived" franchise.