1955 Directed by Douglas Sirk
Two different social classes collide when Cary Scott, a wealthy upper-class widow, falls in love with her much younger and down-to-earth gardener, prompting disapproval and criticism from her children and country club friends.
Tudo o que o Céu Permite, Все, что дозволено небесами
i braced myself for disappointment at the start of this vaunted classic i've been dodging for years-- but i needn't have worried. it seems that growing up in soulless white suburbia, reading thoreau as a kid and knowing there was something- anything- beyond the nightmare of bourgeois conformity was just preparing me for this moment. i'm still stunned at how hard it hit me. my parents never understood but sirk did, and long before i was born
"Cary, let's face it: you were ready for a love affair, but not for love."
Lately I've been fascinated with melodrama, in particular the way its priorities differ from the expectations of what we might loosely refer to as a "good film". In general, we seem to want relatable characters in realistic situations which in turn evoke an emotional response; but in melodrama, everything is backwards. As Sidney Lumet once said, "In a well-written drama, the story comes out of the characters. The characters in a well-written melodrama come out of the story." Perhaps this is why the term has come to take on pejorative connotations in recent years: in melodrama, emotion comes first, even if it's at the expense…
I am of course, holding my left cardigan lapel with my right hand across my chest, staring absent-mindedly out the late fall windows the last of the day's light dying in the tops of the trees first and then descending sobbing uncontrollably at what has been lost forever and what shall never be but what is not yet and what is not yet dreamt as the tears fall onto my pleated circle skirt, appliqued there as diamelle constellations thats all made up until its not <3 <3 <3
God, the production design and cinematography, yes, and the withering portrait of repressive values, but sometimes I think that the artistic virtues of Sirk, of which there are many, are stressed as a means of justifying his chosen field of women's pictures, when even on a script level this is such a compelling movie, and so forcefully acted that its subtext, however key to the picture, is still the subtext under a direct swirl of emotions. It's all great, is what I'm saying. Why has it taken me so long to really dig into Sirk?
88
Douglas Sirk captures gossip and high-class pettiness as vicious language destined to tear family units out internally, sizzling in an attempt to fulfill a reorganization of status and force outsiders to succumb to the dominance of social position. Ron's apathy provides a muted tension which only blares - in stunning, succulent color - when Cary's inner circle (both familial/societal) rises to the pitch of an attack, snarling and spitting when their own exterior is affected by a loving couple separated by class. As such, the middle portion of All That Heaven Allows should be seen as a Technicolor Horror, an angry, 'in the moment' response to a genuine romance. Kicker for me is when Ned answers Cary's phone call with a normal demeanor after previously being bathed in blazing red/electric blue light after shunning his mother. Words hurt, but in Sirk's world, they're currency for stature.
As the great Moira Rose once said, "Gossip is the Devil's telephone, best to just hang up."
Hallmark lifted its entire aesthetic from Norman Rockwell and Douglas Sirk, and we as a society just let it happen.
4/5 (Good, but I prefer Fassbinder's version.)
STOP! STOP PRETENDING THIS IS GOOD! BE FREE OF YOUR IGNORANCE! PLEASE, I BEG OF YOU, DO NOT BELIEVE THIS DESERVES ANY MORE THAN HALF A STAR!
Such a gorgeous technicolor masterpiece. This might be one of the most beautiful looking films I've seen. This is a film that feels ahead of its time in terms of content. Sirk sets up a typical melodrama of the era in the first 30 minutes of the film, but then it pivots just a little bit and you realize what this film is actually about. Jane Wyman and Rock Hudson have such great chemistry together. She gives a wonderful performance in the lead role and I continue to see Rock Hudson as one of the more underrated actors of his era.
Watched at CineNation Presents Screening
this movie was strangely wild? like on one hand it’s straight up just a hallmark movie but on the other hand it’s a trip?
liked the rainbow lighting though
watched for gender + sexuality in film
Oscar Lau 1,000 films
The 15th and the latest edition of TSPDT's 1,000 Greatest Films www.theyshootpictures.com/gf1000.htm The complete list of "1,001-2000" is available HERE.
Peter Stanley 1,222 films
All the films from all the editions, including those subsequently removed, presently totalling 1222. An easy way of seeing how…
tarrdigrade 1,695 films
While you're here, leave me some reccommendations on this other list.
If you're feeling overwhelmed, but still want to squeeze…
