Synopsis
In this government-suggested sequel, Sugata again grows as a judo master, and demonstrates his (and by extension, all Japanese) superiority to the foreign warrior.
1945 ‘續 姿三四郎’ Directed by Akira Kurosawa
In this government-suggested sequel, Sugata again grows as a judo master, and demonstrates his (and by extension, all Japanese) superiority to the foreign warrior.
Zoku Sugata Sanshiro, Zoku Sugata Sanshirô, Judo Saga II, Judo Story II, Sugata Sanshiro Part Two, Sanshiro Sugata Sequel, Sanshiro Sugata, Part Two, Легенда о великом мастере дзюдо 2, La nouvelle légende du grand judo, La légende de judo II, Sugata Sanshiro Fortsetzung, Judo Saga, 스가타 산시로 2
Sanshiro Sugata Part Two is Akira Kurosawa's first sequel and it's so derivative that the only innovation of note is that it is debatably the first sequel in history to be numbered. Part Two is not an overly bad film, but it's simple to the point where it may as well be plotless. It requires some investment in the history of Japanese martial arts to really care about the relatively minor events. It also needs you to overlook the tacky propaganda of Sugata literally fighting to show Japanese supremacy. There is certainly an anti-western sentiment to the film, with boxing seen as a lesser and savage sport, and the titular lead beating up a westerner in the opening scene. Speaking…
You guys have fun marathoning the FAST movies, I did the whole SANSHIRO SUGATA franchise!
This is the ROCKY IV of SANSHIRO SUGATA films.
I could be off base, but a blatant propaganda sequel that attempts to elevate Japan's power over foreigners during a time when Japan was actually surrendering its power to the U.S. makes for a very sympathetic irony. Having just come off the heels of Ozu's work, this film made a lot of sense to me.
For starters, keep in mind that Japan's entire culture had been shifting for decades towards western decadence under Meiji restoration. Traditional foods, dress, fashions, industries, advertising, politics, etc. were becoming overwhelmingly Americanized, essentially dislocating the country from its central identity and ancient traditions. Ozu, of course, had his fair share of qualms with tradition (he certainly criticized harmful traditions, like patriarchal norms and Japanese nationalism),…
I thought Sanshiro Sugata 1 was bad, but this one takes the cake for worst Kurosawa film so far. It doesn’t help that the BFI seem to have a really shitty version of the film (muffled voices etc.).
I think Ip Man 2 does the whole ‘eastern martial arts vs western boxing’ trope much better than it’s done here.
Eh, it’s enjoyable enough.
This film has two “plots” basically, but they don’t even directly connect apart from theme. And, half of this movie is taken up by unimportant events
But, the fight scene at the end was cool
Every single one of Akira Kurosawa’s films that were made during World War II are compromised due to the Japanese Imperialist Government’s strict censorship board. Kurosawa even stated after the fact that while dealing with the Americans during occupational rule was difficult as a filmmaker it was easier than the Japanese censorship board. **During World War II Kurosawa was forced to bend the narrative’s of his movies toward directions that would “rally” the Japanese people and anything too subversive or obviously critical was cut from the movie without his permission. For example the first Sanshiro Sugata (1943) had 18 minutes cut from it before release, and The Most Beautiful (1944), functions more like a recruitment tool than anything else. His…
Sequel to Kurosawa's early film, the financially successful martial-arts drama Sanshiro Sugata-successful enough to demand a sequel, and one (it was made in 1945) where the Japanese government leaned heavily on Kurosawa to include a subplot about Americans being jerks, but what's striking is.......I'll put it this way maybe. I've noticed a number of people on my letterboxd feed have watched STRAY DOG recently, and there's an argument that could be made that the American Buddy Cop film, or elements of it, are really indebted to that film. Likewise, it's sort of fascinating to see a black and white film like this, from the 40s, with a poor, crackling transfer and granular film quality that makes it look fifty years…
Not as visually unmistakably Kurosawa's work as the first movie is (weird, since it obviously came later), but more historically fascinating at it goes much heavier on the anti-American propaganda. Where in the first film the US is a more subtle influence, seen in the clothing worn by the villain and not much apart from that, here Americans are depicted as bullies and maniacal boxing fans, frothing at the mouth with blood lust. It's interesting to see Kurosawa engaging in such simplistic good vs bad drama, given how rigorously he avoids heroes and villains in his later work - on the other hand, boxing really is a pretty brutal activity.
Shout-out to the insane Higaki brothers, they of ghostly laugh and kabuki makeup. Love those guys.
Though not at all subtle, I don't mind the message as it is presented. If it were more baldly jingoism instead of couched in a difference of martial arts, it would be unpleasant, but as a drama about violence's tendency to create violence couched as a struggle of judo against karate and boxing, it has enough layers of distance from the basic Japan vs. America metaphor--and more to it besides. The regrets and honor of the title character have more to say in this story than the brief boxing scenes.
Dear Sanshiro Sugata Part Two,
It’s not you, it’s me. We are simply from different times, you and I. You’ve been fashioned for a wartime society, in need of some entertainment and a win— and I’ve come looking for deep themes and dynamic characters. I think we just want different things.
Your younger self, Sanshiro Sugata part one, had more focus on the journey and discoveries of the hero… but now— and I hate to say this— but I think you’ve grown in a way that’s disingenuous to who and what you once were. Now you seem to be more fond of simple fights, and patriotically proving the worth of the Japanese spirt against the American one. And I…
The outstanding quality of the early Kurosawa films is their sparseness. He knew the limits of what he would be allowed to depict, what the logistical limitations were, and what his own capabilities were, and didn’t aim much higher. This allows for modest, but concentrated efforts (albeit in the case of this film, much more mediocre compared to the first Sanshiro and The Men Who Tread... ) that makes for the basis of his much more ambitious films to come.
For his third feature Kurosawa was encouraged to make a sequel to the highly popular Sanshiro Sugata and though his enthusiasm for the project was lacking, this is a satisfying follow up to the entertaining story of a young judo disciple in 1880s Japan, picking up shortly after the first left off.
Made just as Japan was losing the war, there is anti-American propaganda within it but only when required, this was no doubt forced into the film and Kurosawa evidently didn't care for it as it quickly reverts to being a character drama. Though a rather superfluous addition, it does develop Sugata's arc further - now that he has achieved success he's faced with the problems that this brings,…
It took Rocky Balboa nearly a decade and three sequels to do what Sanshiro Sugata managed in just one. Kurosawa's third feature is a "government suggested" sequel to his debut, acting as a literal follow up to the Sanshiro Sugata story, whilst also providing a spiritual successor to the Most Beautiful, at least in terms of its form.
We can be thankful that the propaganda isn't quite as on the nose as in that previous film, but it is still very much there. The idea this time out was to show the courage and strength and, most importantly, honour of the Japanese warrior by pitting judo wrestler Sugata against first an American boxer, and then against the karate practicing brothers…
Enjoyable at times but quite uneven. More of the conflict between the rival jujitsu and judo schools with some inversions.
Overall it feels flimsier and less developed than the first. And the picture quality is noticeably degraded at the end. It would be hard to contemporaneously have seen a genius emerging after this and the previous propaganda film, both of which feel like a step back from the first Sanshiro movie.
So many Rocky vibes from this! Sure this one was nowhere near as good as its predecessor, but considering the historical context of the time its existence makes total sense. There are a couple of good Kurosawa takes here (particularly at the end!), but Part 2 is clearly hindered from being a better film because of Kurosawa's burden of making a government sanctioned sequel. I do think that OG Sanshiro Sugata is a more artful and gratifying film, but this wasn't as bad as I thought it would be all things considered.
Definitely an improvement over the first. This happens to be the first Kurosawa movie without Takashi Shimura I’ve seen! And it may supposedly be propaganda but I don’t think that’s a fault at all, I like seeing overconfident Americans lose to a Judo master. The fight choreography is definitely better, and therefore the fight scenes are more captivating, especially the last- although I still think swordplay is much more Kurosawa’s strong suit. But I think the ending does a great job of completing the title character’s arc, and for that, I consider this a good and necessary sequel.
Sanshiro Sugata, the kinda guy who will stop your boxing match and will throw out of the ring.
sanshrio sugata part two is the highly anticipated 1945 follow-up to akira kurosawa's debut film, a showing that quickly solidified itself as one of the more influential japanese works of its time. this piece picks up right where we left off with the last one, a young man caught in the lore of his greatness. everybody just wants to mess with the man, which isn't surprising... you create more and more enemies when all you do is win.
with this being said, this film got straight to the point, just as the preceding one did. some may say that this work was "plotless", but i just don't see how you can't understand the intentional simplicity of the story, especially considering…
Kurosawa Filmography Part 4: While this really didn't add a lot from the original, I read that this was only created due to studio pressure so that makes sense. I still enjoyed it and liked seeing the characters again. The stakes were certainly raised and the ending showdown was fun, but there wasn't anything else that was very memorable.
this was bad honestly. the plot was all over the floor.
High and Low | Drunken Angel | The Hidden Fortress | The Men Who Tread on Tiger’s Tail | Sanshiro Sugata | Sanshiro Sugata Pt. II | Yojimbo | Sanjuro | Scandal | Ikiru | Dersu Uzala | I Live In Fear | Stray Dog | Kagemusha | Rhapsody in August | Dreams | Rashomon | No Regrets For Our Youth | The Most Beautiful | One Wonderful Sunday | Madadayo | Red Beard | The Quiet Duel | Dodes’ka-den | The Lower Depths | The Idiot | The Bad Sleep Well | Throne of Blood | Seven Samurai | Ran
I guess now I know the origin of a lot of movies I already love like Karate Kid and the Rocky franchise.
Really good movie. The fight scene in the mountains is haunting.
Josh 1,361 films
Updated: January 15, 2020 Created: January 19, 2013 View More Lists Follow Me
——————————————————————— CRITERION CHALLENGE 2021 ➔ ———————————————————————
The…
Gabe 1,344 films
Master list of every film I've seen from the entire Asian continent, from West to East to South.
Nate 2,257 films
Everything on the brand new Criterion Channel Streaming service. (As of 11/10/20) Sort list by last added for latest additions…
mishima24 17,251 films
Constantly updating. If you know of something I should add, or I added something erroneously here, please let me know…
Michael 184 films
(Last Updated: 26 February 2018)
Eclipse is a selection of lost, forgotten, or overshadowed classics in simple, affordable editions. Each…
Stephen Bush 2,286 films
The Criterion Channel launched on April 8, 2019. The calendar of thematic programming highlights an eclectic mix of classic and…
Mohammed 1,431 films
David Blakeslee 4,028 films
Updated on 1/16/2021 (includes titles announced for April 2021 release) - A list, arranged in order of original release, of…
Meg 2,247 films
All the films Criterion distributes, including out of print titles, stuff in Eclipse sets, and their stuff on Hulu Plus.…
MovieBuFF1138 222 films
A list of film firsts. Please help add to/correct this list if you can. The firsts are in the notes.…
Gabe 980 films
Master list to keep track of East Asian films I've seen (Gonna take awhile to remember it all lol).
Accepting…
Eden4 1,750 films