John DeCarli’s review published on Letterboxd:
A Ghost Story is a huge step forward in lyricism and stylistic confidence compared to David Lowery's Ain't Them Bodies Saints. It's a singular work with some moments of haunting beauty and others of metaphysical introspection, even if I did feel at times that it lacked a clarity of vision.
Lowery wrings emotion from the authenticity and naturalism of Rooney Mara and Casey Affleck, but the real stars are those strange glints of light you see on walls, or particles of dust illuminated by windows. The physicality of a particular space becomes integral to this tale of a spirit connected, unstuck in time, to a simple home, but capturing the feeling of a location aesthetically is also among the film's greatest strengths. Aided by a square aspect ratio with rounded edges, Lowery gives a compelling density to his images that makes the central house feel solid and real, a space with genuine stories to tell.
A Ghost Story is an ambitious film in its own quiet way. With very little dialogue and an emphasis on stillness it addresses complex and wide-ranging thematic issues. When these aesthetic and thematic ambitions coalesce it creates some of the film's best moments. One sequence, for example, intimately bathes Mara's face in a warm light as she listens to an emotional piece of music, only to strip away that intimacy and warmth in a gutting cut forward in time. When these concerns are out of synch, however, I feel a bit of shakiness in Lowery's vision. The film uses many long takes, for example, but not all have the heft to justify our prolonged attention. A clunky extended monologue later in the film also feels strained and out of place.
Ultimately, though, A Ghost Story is a quiet and thoughtful tone piece, an eerie and oddly comforting presence we don't often see at the movies.
- I loved the interactions with the other ghost. They're funny and devastating, without breaking the tone of the rest of the film.
- I know that it allows the movie to explore more of its themes, but the movie looses an intimacy when Mara leaves. It would have been a completely different film, but maybe a smaller and more focused experience if it all took place in her final days before moving out.
- The experience of packing and moving always felt melancholy to me in a weird, ineffable way, and this film really captures that feeling.
- I know it's called A Ghost Story, but I think it was a misstep to play up a few moments of tension, like the bulldozer or Mara pounding on the glass for a laugh.
- There are a few moments with some genuine chills, like both ghost disappearances.
- The movie is very thoughtful, and the ending is impactful, though I'm not sure I totally get the point. My best guess: everything ends, so it's the human connections we experience that really matter. I'm not sure how the note plays into that.
- Beautiful music and sound design. It's a quiet film, but it knows how to make the most of sound.
- I feel bad that Mara had to sit there and eat that whole pie.