Amazing technical and artistic touches, but most of the performances didn't touch me, and I was constantly distracted by how weirdly British Kim Hunter sounded when her being American (as she was!) was such a plot point. Some of the plot also lacked internal logic but hey it's supernatural romance whaddyawant.

Extremely visually imaginative, powerfully emotional, good use of music and talking about music, and like so many Disney things started rolling straight out of my brain the moment it was done.

Cuaron's style is top-notch, and the sense of a living world is amazing, but the story itself was not.