jadawson’s review published on Letterboxd:
Not as interesting as the original but still a good bit of fun. Will Turner has transformed into full pirate and Elizabeth Swann has become an expert swordsman but you can look past some of that because you like the characters. Davy Jones was an excellent new character and the scenes on his boat were often the best of the movie.
The entire sequence with the tribe on the island is hard to overlook though. both with how the tribesmen are portrayed and with how preposterous some of the action set pieces are. These are pirates not world class athletes.