loureviews’s review published on Letterboxd:
#35 in the George Cukor filmography.
"You wanna put out the light?"
I haven't seen this for a long time, but it was sitting on my Sky+, and I have been watching a lot of Shakespeare related material lately, so I thought it was time to revisit.
This was the role for which Ronald Colman won a leading man Oscar as the actor who is such a method player he lets the role of Othello drive him to murder.
It's a noirish concept which is directed well by George Cukor, but it is such a nonsense in its construction that despite a fine scene half way through, as Tony (Colman) wanders through shadowed streets with Iago's voice in his head and staccato violins on the soundtrack, it loses its way.
Shelley Winters has an early role as the actor's unfortunate mistress, a slinky blonde in a silky nightgown. Colman's jealousy and insanity drives him to do a terrible thing, but it doesn't ring true, and I am sorry to say that what passed as award-winning material back then looks suspiciously like overacting now.
In all conscience, I can't raise this one's rating.