loureviews’s review published on Letterboxd:
A disappointing adaptation of one of my favourite Thomas Hardy stories, 'The Melancholy Hussar of the German Legion'.
The love story between the lonely German hussar and the girl trapped into an unwanted engagement should simmer with passion as it moves to the eventual tragedy, but this all feels just a bit too chocolate box and safe.
Emma Fielding, as the girl whose head is turned, looks and sounds too modern and isn't my idea of the character of Frances (actually, Hardy named her Phyllis) at all. Jean-Marc Barr is slightly better as Matthaus. There are character actors a-plenty in the cast: Simon Callow (too much bluster), John Sessions, Jack Shepherd, Lynda Bellingham, Gareth Hale, Andrew Tiernan.
Perfunctorily directed by Stuart St Paul, best known for his 1980s pop videos and as a stuntman, this was an attempt to cash on the period boom which followed 'Pride and Prejudice', but it failed to provide the requisite happy ending - there are few of those in the works of Hardy - instead presenting a ridiculous denouement which cheapens the story.