And my five stars goes to:
+1 H. P. Lovecraft
+1 A certain breathless atmosphere of "Alien" and "Abyss"
+1 Kristen Stewart
+1 no need to explain happenings with a stupid plot or the past of the characters. Just people facing strange things.
+1 I love everything that comes from the sea (especially, the darkness in its depths makes me panic)
All the rest... meh