kev’s review published on Letterboxd:
There is a twist halfway through this film that completely surprised me and placed me at a compromising position in regards to the characters. It was a brave choice, and while the film isn't really ABOUT this new detail, it helps to inform the characters and poses some startling questions.
Rudderless is the directorial debut of William H. Macy, and could probably best be described as a musical dramedy. While it certainly leans more heavily on the drama elements, there is enough levity to make it a hybrid. It is focused on a grieving father (Billy Crudup) who, losing his son in a terrible ordeal, is not living life to the fullest. He's pretty much broke down; he lost his lucrative job at an ad agency, and is now living out in a boat. Things change when he discovers his late son had a knack for writing songs, and begins to play those songs. Long story short, he ends up teaming up with Anton Yelchin and they start a band.
Billy Crudup's performance here as a father who's trying his hardest to repress his emotions in an attempt to get on with his life is incredibly moving. He nails the role perfectly, and it is definitely one of his best performances, if not his best, to date. Anton Yelchin is here in an excellent supporting turn, and his rapport with Crudup is excellent. Their dynamic is one of the most pleasing elements of the film. Laurence Fishburne also pops up for a bit, and Macy himself steps out from behind the director's chair for a few minutes as well.
The key ingredient here is the music though. The soundtrack for this film is truly excellent, with each song being well written and memorable. The emotional connection Crudup feels towards the songs also helps to enhance their impact and meaning. The final song, and performance, in particular - had me almost choking up.
Look, it's not some grandstanding film that will go down in the history books, but it is an effective little indie that hits hard when it wants too. Throw in some strong performances and some wicked tunes, and you've got yourself a winner. I suggest checking this one out if you've got the time.