Matt Hurt’s review published on Letterboxd :
It took a bit of time for me to warm up to this documentary and get past the more (to be honest) moronic parts of one of the subjects. But once I put thy aside, I recognized that this is a pretty good documentary showing the behind the scenes of a small media circus and what goes on after the news coverage ends. More importantly, it shows how this bizarre story affected the two men's lives in surprising ways.
All in all, Finders Keepers is the feature length equivalent of its subject; a quintessential local news affiliate "wacky news" segment. It's worth a watch if you're bored and in the mood for something a bit unconventional and bizarre.