My girlfriend loves this movie and I don't know what that says about her, and I really don't know what that says about me.
I let my 10-year-old stay up late with me last night and watch this movie. She'd never seen a Wes Anderson film before. I can't explain what a treat it was to watch her giggle with joy and delight throughout. Being a parent is incredibly frustrating and a pain in the ass a lot of the time, but there are few greater experiences in life than the vicarious pleasure you get when introducing something wonderful to your kid.
This was the first really great pirate movie since the original Treasure Island. Unfortunately, it was the last one, too.