Published Updated

Letterboxd's Picks for Best Picture

A good companion piece to the recent list made by letterboxd staff. It is often said that The Academy doesn't always choose the nominee that *actually* deserves Best Picture. And according to the average ratings of the nominees on Letterboxd, that is true about 76% of the time!
Some Notes:
--Decades Ranked Highest Average to Lowest: 1970's (3.86), 2010's (3.80), 1990's (3.79), 2000's (3.75), 1980's (3.66), 1960's (3.65), 1940's (3.63), 1950's (3.58), 1930's (3.4)
--26% of the time the highest rated film won, 20% of the time it was at or almost (in even numbered nomination years) in the exact middle , and 16% of time the winner was the lowest
--The decade that had the most "correct" winners are…

Read notes

There are 10 historical films in this list.

  • Grand Illusion

    11

  • Judgment at Nuremberg

    34

  • Lawrence of Arabia

    35

  • America America

    36

  • The Lion in Winter

    41

  • Z

    42

  • The Right Stuff

    56

  • Amadeus

    57

  • Schindler's List

    66

  • Saving Private Ryan

    71