Competent, and while it may be more faithful the actual events, the Gus Van Sant version To Die For has so much more personality.
'Wait, why is he doing that?... Ooooooh!: The Movie'
Like The Martian except on Earth (so, The Earthling?). I'm glad they went with a seasoned vet like Redford instead of just putting some Michael Fassbender or something on a boat. With so little dialogue and no backstory this really needed someone well-versed with the "method" method of acting. Plus Redford's craggy features easily pass for wind-beaten mariner.