Nonsense. Sometimes charming and funny nonsense, but still nonsense. The wrong couple is the focus, Taye Diggs is not super convincing as an asshole, and this isn't how sports journalism works.
Look, the defense she makes... doesn't make any sense for this case. But if you ignore that, it's just such a sophisticated, mature romance, and a good satire/takedown of the way the justice system works. There is so much here - the neighbour and his song! Flirting in the courtroom! Spanking!