RSS feed for Josh Rosenthal

Favorite films

Recent activity


Recent reviews

  • Black Mirror: Bandersnatch

    Black Mirror: Bandersnatch


    yeah, it’s cool. enjoyed the concept, though it could have been ironed out a little bit. it’s slightly difficult to talk about this because i don’t know if i picked the right path, or the wrong path, or what this even is? i do wish that it would actually end at each ending, though, for i was left unsatisfied after picking random choices over and over again, not realizing that those constituted the “ending,” only to be shocked when a choice i accidentally made took me all the way to the credits. flawed but fun.

  • The Old Man & the Gun

    The Old Man & the Gun


    so cute and light. probably the nicest heist movie I’ve ever seen. very impressive cinematography and pacing, feels very smooth and never oversteps its limitations in terms of scope and plausibility. if this does turn out to be Redford’s swan song, it sure is a good one.

Popular reviews

  • Arrival



    me, before Arrival: i love sci-fi!! this will be such a fun time!
    me, after Arrival, with tears in my eyes: oh ok

  • A Ghost Story

    A Ghost Story


    theater usher: so did you like the movie

    me, my voice cracking and crumpled tissues falling out of my pockets: ʸᵉᵃʰ ᶦᵗ ʷᵃˢ ᵒᵏ

    theater usher: excuse me?

    me, sobbing and melting into the ground as my spirit leaves my physical body: oh my god i'm so sorry

    THE film of a lifetime. so silently impactful and grand. it's all about time.