Billy Wilson’s review published on Letterboxd:
I really enjoyed this movie a lot. The people I watched it with did not and that was because they thought it was too sad. I disagree with them. While the movie is sad, the chemistry between Cooper and Gaga is absolutely stunning. We really get invested in their relationship and how much they love each other. I didn't get emotionally torn at the end, but throughout it overall, it hit the right emotional notes. We don't always get a happy ending, but the journey that we were taken on with this one was incredible to say the least. A great movie and just a great musical drama.